Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito will not participate in a major climate-liability case brought by Boulder, Colorado, officials against Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil, the court’s clerk said in a Monday letter to counsel.
“Justice Alito has determined that he will not continue to participate in this case,” the letter stated, without giving a reason. Arguments are set for Oct. 5, the first day of the new term. An eight-justice court will hear whether state tort suits over alleged fossil-fuel deception and climate damages may proceed — a dispute with nationwide implications for similar cases.
Alito does not appear to hold stock in Exxon or Suncor, but his financial disclosures show holdings in other oil companies, including ConocoPhillips and Phillips 66. CBS News (opens in new tab) reported that those oil and gas holdings, listed in his 2025 disclosure report, are the likely reason he stepped aside. The advocacy group Consumer Watchdog had pressed for recusal, arguing he could indirectly benefit from a ruling favorable to the industry.
Alito had resisted such calls earlier this year. In May, after watchdog groups asked the Senate Judiciary Committee to look into his participation, a Supreme Court spokeswoman told NBC News that “Justice Alito does not have a financial interest in any party” and that the court’s legal counsel had advised him that recusal was not required, SCOTUSblog (opens in new tab) reported. In January, Alito withdrew from another oil and gas case, Chevron USA Inc. v. Plaquemines Parish, less than a week before argument; that time the clerk’s letter cited his financial interest in ConocoPhillips, the parent company of Burlington Resources, which remained a party in the lower court, according to SCOTUSblog (opens in new tab).
Energy companies, backed by the Trump administration, argue the suits threaten the industry and that state courts are the wrong forum for global climate issues. Boulder officials say the companies misled the public about fossil fuels’ climate harms and should help pay adaptation costs.
Jonathan H. Adler, writing at the Volokh Conspiracy blog hosted by Reason, called the recusal likely bad news for the companies, describing Alito as “among the more preemption-friendly justices on the Court.” The court has not ruled, and eight justices will now hear the case.