The Justice Department sued the State of Maryland on Thursday, challenging a new state law and two county ordinances that bar law enforcement officers, including federal agents, from covering their faces on duty and require them to identify themselves. The complaint, filed Oct. 1 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, also names Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown, the Maryland Police Training and Standards Commission, Prince George’s County and Montgomery County as defendants.
The complaint says the state law, known as SB-1, requires officers to “wear identification on [their] outermost layer of clothing while in the performance of duty in the state” and to identify themselves verbally on request, and that an officer who violates the face-covering ban is subject to a civil fine of up to $1,500. CBS News Baltimore (opens in new tab) reported that the law passed in April, was signed by Gov. Wes Moore in May and took effect Oct. 1. The department asks the court to declare the laws invalid and to block them with preliminary and permanent injunctions.
“Under the U.S. Constitution, the Supremacy Clause provides that states and localities do not have the authority to regulate the Federal Government,” Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr. said in a department statement. “These Maryland state and local laws are a direct regulation of federal law enforcement operations and threaten severe consequences for officers and public safety alike,” said Assistant Attorney General Brett A. Shumate. “The Federal Government, not state and local governments, gets to decide which equipment federal officers may or may not wear when performing their official duties.”
The complaint states that “Federal law enforcement agents and officers cannot and will not comply with the Challenged Laws,” and cites instances in which it says immigration officers in the region were doxed online, including an Aug. 16 incident involving a deportation officer. It also quotes a May 12 letter from Brown to Moore in which Brown wrote that there was a “high likelihood” a court would find that applying the law’s face-covering ban or identification requirement to federal officers would violate the Supremacy Clause.
The department said Maryland is the eighth state it has sued over such rules, and listed earlier suits involving New York, Virginia, Connecticut, New Jersey, California, Philadelphia and Milwaukee. It said the United States “has secured preliminary relief from each court to have ruled on mask ban / ID requirements so far.”
A spokesperson for the attorney general’s office declined to comment, CBS News Baltimore (opens in new tab) reported. Moore’s office said in a statement, “We don’t comment on ongoing litigation, but Governor Moore has been clear that an untrained, unqualified, and unaccountable ICE is unacceptable. Maryland will always defend transparency, accountability and due process,” Fox 5 DC (opens in new tab) reported. Rep. Glenn Ivey, a Maryland Democrat, disputed the department’s safety argument: “All this nonsense about, they’re in more danger than other cops, I think is ridiculous. And unsubstantiated. There’s no factual basis for that kind of a claim,” he said, according to NBC Washington (opens in new tab).