The Justice Department sued Alaska election officials on Thursday. It asks a federal judge to block certification of next month’s U.S. Senate result if Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan loses to Democrat Mary Peltola and the votes cast for a second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., would have changed the outcome. The case, United States v. Alaska, is before U.S. District Judge Sharon L. Gleason, according to Courthouse News and Election Law Blog.
The complaint argues that Sullivan Jr.’s place on the ballot could mislead the senator’s supporters. “For example, some supporters of Senator Sullivan likely will inadvertently vote for Daniel J. Sullivan,” it says, according to NBC News (opens in new tab). The department relies on a passage in the National Voter Registration Act about protecting “the integrity of the electoral process.” It asks that certification be put on hold pending an investigation into whether votes for Sullivan Jr. were meant for the senator.
President Donald Trump told reporters Friday that he directed the lawsuit. “I’m the one that said do it,” he said, according to NBC News (opens in new tab). The same day the suit was filed, Attorney General Todd Blanche told reporters “it is not DOJ’s intention to, and it’s never our intention to, improperly interfere with elections,” the outlet reported. A DOJ spokesperson said Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy “was intended to mislead voters and compromise the fairness of the ballot.”
Sullivan Jr., a former teacher from Petersburg, has said he is running on his own convictions. Alaska officials tried to keep him off the ballot, but state courts, including the Alaska Supreme Court, let him stay on. The November ballot lists “Dan S. Sullivan” as the registered Republican and incumbent, and “Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.” with no party. In the August all-party primary, Peltola won 49.5%, the senator 41.4% and Sullivan Jr. 2.5%, NBC News (opens in new tab) reported.
Election-law experts said the case is unlikely to succeed. David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation & Research said “the administration has absolutely no authority to tell Alaska when or how to certify the results of its Senate election.” Election-law scholar Derek Muller wrote on Election Law Blog that the legal argument “is one of the worst ones I’ve ever seen.” The AP noted the suit only becomes relevant if the senator loses.