An Egyptian court on Tuesday convicted Lina Attalah, editor-in-chief of the independent news site Mada Masr (opens in new tab), of managing a website without a license. It fined her 3 million Egyptian pounds, about $53,400, and ordered the site closed and its equipment confiscated.
The fine was the maximum allowed for the offense, according to the BBC and DW (opens in new tab). Attalah had rejected the charge. Security personnel took her into custody in the courthouse after the verdict, Mada Masr (opens in new tab) reported. The outlet said she was released several hours later, once it had paid the fine in full.
The case was heard by Judge Mohamed Mubarak of the New Cairo Misdemeanour Court. Hossam Bahgat, executive director of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, attended the hearing. He told Mada Masr (opens in new tab) that the judge cleared the courtroom except for Attalah and her lawyers, and that plainclothes officers then filed in. The court rejected all of the defense's procedural requests, including requests to present documents and call witnesses, Mada Masr (opens in new tab) reported.
Bahgat said the judge then appointed a lawyer from outside Attalah's eight-member defense team, over her objection. “In an even more shocking turn, the judge proceeded to dictate motions on behalf of this lawyer - who had not uttered a single word - and entered them into the official record,” he told AFP, as quoted by the BBC.
While she was being released, Attalah learned she had been sentenced in absentia in 2024 to one year in prison on charges of publishing false news and running an unlicensed website, Mada Masr (opens in new tab) said. Her lawyers have challenged that ruling, and a retrial hearing is set for Nov. 11. Lawyer Hassan al-Azhari said the outlet would appeal the closure order, DW (opens in new tab) reported.
Mada Masr (opens in new tab) was founded in 2013. Egyptian authorities have blocked the site inside the country since 2017. The outlet says it first applied for a license in 2018 after a new media law was passed. It says it learned only in 2022 that the application had been rejected, and that a newer application has been pending since 2023, DW (opens in new tab) reported.
Egyptian authorities say they respect freedom of expression but insist that media outlets must comply with the law, protect national security and counter misinformation, DW (opens in new tab) reported. The Event Log did not find a government statement on Tuesday's verdict itself.
Rights groups condemned the ruling. Amnesty International called it “a crushing blow to press freedom.” “If Egypt can put in custody one of its most respected editors and shut down her newsroom, no independent journalist in the country is safe,” said Sara Qudah, regional director of the Committee to Protect Journalists. Bassam Khawaja of Human Rights Watch (opens in new tab) called the conviction “a complete travesty of justice.” U.S. Sen. Chris Van Hollen said “journalism is not a crime,” according to DW (opens in new tab).