A federal judge in Manhattan ruled Monday that the Justice Department broke the law when it fired Maurene Comey, a federal prosecutor and the daughter of former FBI Director James Comey, in July 2025.

In a 55-page opinion, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman found that the firing violated the separation of powers, the Administrative Procedure Act, and Comey’s Fifth Amendment due process and statutory rights, as AP summarized the ruling. The government had argued that the attorney general could remove an assistant U.S. attorney at will under Article II of the Constitution. Furman wrote that the argument “flies in the face of nearly two centuries of Supreme Court precedent,” and that accepting it “would be to unsettle the very equilibrium established by this Nation’s constitutional system.”

The department conceded in court filings that the firing was not for cause and not based on her performance, Furman noted. He rejected a second argument, that the firing itself amounted to an implicit finding of cause, saying that “the argument borders on frivolous.” He also found that Comey received none of the procedural protections the Civil Service Reform Act requires, such as advance written notice and a chance to respond.

Comey had spent about a decade in the Southern District of New York and worked on the prosecutions of Ghislaine Maxwell and Sean “Diddy” Combs. Furman ordered her retroactively reinstated, with back pay, from her July 16, 2025, firing through Dec. 20, 2025, the date the court inferred she took another job. She is now in private practice and no longer seeks to return to the office, AP reported.

The judge reserved judgment on Comey’s First Amendment claim. Her lawsuit alleged she was fired because of her father or her perceived political views. Furman said he was inclined to dismiss that claim as largely moot, and he gave her until Nov. 9 to argue why it should not be, according to CNBC (opens in new tab) and the opinion.

The Justice Department said it “disagrees with this decision, which obstructs President Trump’s constitutional authority to fire individuals who wield executive power on his behalf,” and that it intends to appeal, according to USA Today (opens in new tab) and the New York Post (opens in new tab). An appeal would follow a final judgment. Comey’s lawyers said in a statement, “This hard-earned victory belongs to Ms. Comey, to all civil servants, and to all fighting for the rule of law.”

Fox News (opens in new tab) noted that Furman was nominated by President Barack Obama in 2011 and once worked as a prosecutor in the same office. James Comey, whom Trump fired as FBI director in 2017, faces a pending indictment accusing him of threatening Trump with an Instagram photo of seashells forming “86 47.” He denies wrongdoing.