A constitutional climate case brought by 15 young Canadians went to trial Monday in Federal Court in Vancouver. It is the first youth-led climate lawsuit in Canada to get a full trial. Filed in 2019 as La Rose v. His Majesty the King, it was first dismissed and then sent to trial by the Federal Court of Appeal in 2023.
The plaintiffs, now aged 17 to 25, argue that the federal government’s conduct on climate change violates their rights to life, liberty and security of the person under Section 7 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. They are asking the court to declare those rights violated and to order a science-based climate recovery plan, CBC News (opens in new tab) and the plaintiffs’ lawyers said. Their key target is the Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act, which they say puts Canada on an emissions path inconsistent with a safe and livable future.
In her opening, plaintiffs’ counsel Catherine Boies Parker said the case is not about whether climate change is real. She said it turns on whether the government is “constitutionally required to stop making it worse,” CBC reported. She told the court, “This case is about the most fundamental rights of children in Canada,” according to AFP.
Government lawyer BJ Wray said the plaintiffs seek “an obligation on the government that the government has no way of satisfying.” He argued that “climate change is a global problem that can only be remedied with a global solution,” and that the plaintiffs could suffer climate harms even if Ottawa were bound to specific targets, AFP reported. The government is not disputing climate science, according to Columbia University’s Sabin Center, as cited by CBC.
The first plaintiff to testify was Kira Young, 20, of Yellowknife. She described her family fleeing an August 2023 wildfire. “I was terrified,” she said, according to AFP.
The evidence phase is scheduled to run through Nov. 20, with closing arguments expected in February. CBC reported that the plaintiffs plan to call eight expert witnesses and the government four. A key legal question is whether Section 7 imposes a “positive obligation” on the government to protect people from climate harms. Canada’s target is a 40% to 45% cut in emissions from 2005 levels by 2030, and AFP reported that Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government has signaled it may miss it.