The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday allowed the Trump administration to resume, for now, deporting migrants to countries that are not identified in their removal orders, NPR (opens in new tab) reports, handing the White House another interim win on immigration enforcement.
The court’s brief, unsigned order did not explain its reasoning for staying the district court’s Feb. 25 judgment. Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson said they would have denied the government’s request but did not write separately, the order shows. The court also treated the application as a petition for review, granted it and set the case for argument in its December session, according to the order and NPR (opens in new tab). The parties must brief whether the district court had jurisdiction, whether it could grant classwide relief, whether the government’s third-country guidance is lawful, and any other questions the government considers appropriate. SCOTUSblog (opens in new tab) says a decision will likely come next year.
Solicitor General John Sauer had told the court the third-country policy is “an essential tool to remove certain aliens, including some of the worst criminal aliens,” arguing the nation is harmed when removals stall. The administration says it has used the practice to send tens of thousands of noncitizens to Mexico and countries in Africa and Latin America when home countries refused returns, NPR (opens in new tab) reports. DHS has argued that diplomatic assurances to Secretary of State Marco Rubio that a destination will not persecute or torture a person should suffice.
Immigrant advocates at the National Immigration Litigation Alliance, representing people facing removal, told the court that class members removed without meaningful notice have faced prolonged detention, beatings, sexual assault, disappearance and chain refoulement, lawyer Trina Realmuto wrote in filings quoted by NPR (opens in new tab). U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy in Boston had blocked the practice, saying it violated due process; Tuesday’s action is the third time the justices have rejected Murphy’s efforts to pause the removals, NPR (opens in new tab) notes.
The 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had upheld Murphy’s ruling on Sept. 18 and then dissolved a stay that had let removals continue, Fox News (opens in new tab) and The Hill (opens in new tab) reported; the administration filed its emergency application on Sept. 24, after Attorney General Todd Blanche said it would seek Supreme Court relief, Reuters (opens in new tab) reported. DHS has described canceled flights and diplomatic friction under Murphy’s rulings. The Supreme Court’s conservative majority has generally given presidents wide latitude at the border, including a 6–3 ruling last summer upholding broad power to end Temporary Protected Status, NPR (opens in new tab) recalls. Tuesday’s stay is temporary; the December argument will test whether the policy survives fuller review.