A coalition led by New York Attorney General Letitia James went to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on Thursday to challenge the Environmental Protection Agency’s repeal of most of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards for fossil fuel-fired power plants, according to the coalition’s court filing and Reuters (opens in new tab).

The filing lists 21 states, Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, the District of Columbia, Chicago, New York City and the City and County of Denver as petitioners. The Illinois and California attorneys general and Reuters (opens in new tab) described a coalition of 25; the attorneys general’s announcements did not name New Mexico, which appears on the filing.

The EPA rule, published in the Federal Register on Sept. 17, repeals the emission guidelines for existing fossil fuel-fired steam generating units, the carbon-capture-based standards for coal-fired units undergoing large modifications, and the carbon-capture-based standards for new base-load gas turbines, according to the Federal Register notice attached to the filing. It takes effect Nov. 16.

The coalition argues that the EPA abandoned the limits without properly considering reasonable alternatives or the health and climate costs of more pollution, and that the repeal is arbitrary and capricious, according to the Illinois attorney general (opens in new tab)’s office. The coalition also sent a notice of intent to sue over the EPA’s failure to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from many existing gas-fired plants, the office said.

“Dismantling these protections is a betrayal of American families, and the stakes are too high to allow this administration to once again put profits over people,” James said, according to Reuters (opens in new tab). “Rolling back emission standards for power plants is an affront to the American people,” California Attorney General Rob Bonta said in a statement. “Americans cannot afford the impact of unchecked climate change,” said Illinois Attorney General (opens in new tab) Kwame Raoul.

An EPA spokesperson told Spectrum News the agency does not comment on pending litigation. When it finalized the repeal, the EPA said the move would save $310 billion and that the 2024 standards exceeded its authority by requiring control technologies that were not adequately demonstrated. The Federal Register notice puts the power sector’s compliance cost savings at $160 billion from 2026 to 2047, using a 3% discount rate. “The Trump Administration has come in to protect American energy and to make sure you can afford to keep the lights on,” EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said at the time.

The Washington Examiner (opens in new tab) reported that industry figures had argued the carbon-capture technology the 2024 rule relied on does not yet exist, and that environmental groups have also sued over the repeal.