Stevie Wonder, whose legal name is Stevland Morris, sued Carmen Efferson on Thursday, Oct. 22, in Los Angeles County Superior Court, seeking to remove her from a house he owns in Los Angeles, according to copies of the complaint obtained by Billboard (opens in new tab), Rolling Stone (opens in new tab), TMZ (opens in new tab) and the Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab). Accounts of the location differ: Billboard (opens in new tab) and Rolling Stone (opens in new tab) describe a three-bedroom house in the Hollywood Hills, while the Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab) places it on Oak Glen Drive in Studio City.
The complaint says Efferson has lived in the house since July 1988 under an oral agreement with Wonder that required no rent. Efferson confirmed to Billboard (opens in new tab) on Oct. 23 that she was engaged to Wonder when she moved in, though the two never married.
According to the complaint, Wonder’s representatives tried three times in July to enter the house for an inspection tied to renewing the property insurance, and Efferson refused them entry. An email included in the complaint, dated July 25 by the Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab) and sent to Wonder’s attorney David Huff according to Billboard (opens in new tab) and Rolling Stone (opens in new tab), asked him to “please refrain from your rascist [sic] coldblooded ‘white male privilege’ tone” and said, “Regarding your ORDERS of entering into the place where I am living, I do not consent.”
In a reply included in the filing, Huff said the inspection notice had been written by his law partner, Tempestt Tatum, whom he described as “neither racist, coldblooded, white nor male,” according to the exhibits as quoted by Rolling Stone (opens in new tab). The Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab) reports that, according to the complaint, Efferson wrote in a July 27 email that she would “immediately contact law enforcement” if Wonder’s representatives tried again to enter.
The complaint says Wonder’s lawyers then revoked the arrangement and served a 30-day notice to vacate by Aug. 27, which Efferson did not meet. According to the complaint as described by the Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab), a three-day notice followed on Oct. 6, and Wonder’s lawyers say they gave her “three additional opportunities to permit entry” for an inspection, to which she did not respond.
In the complaint, Wonder asks a judge to order Efferson out of the house and seeks forfeiture of the oral agreement, legal fees and statutory damages of up to $600, which Billboard (opens in new tab) and Rolling Stone (opens in new tab) report the complaint ties to the lapsed property insurance.
Efferson declined to comment on the lawsuit to Billboard (opens in new tab) and did not immediately respond to the Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab)’ multiple requests for response on Friday. A legal representative for Wonder did not comment to the Los Angeles Times (opens in new tab), and a rep for Wonder did not immediately respond to Rolling Stone (opens in new tab)’s request for comment.